GST 2.0: Balancing Revenue Loss with Economic Momentum
India’s Goods and Services Tax (GST) system, introduced in 2017, is on the verge of a significant overhaul with the proposed GST 2.0. This reform aims to simplify the existing multi-tier tax structure into a two-tier system, potentially reducing government revenue by an estimated ₹85,000 crore annually. Despite this substantial loss, experts and reports, including one from SBI Research, suggest that the economy could gain significant momentum. How can a reform that reduces government revenue simultaneously boost economic growth? Let’s explore the mechanics, implications, and potential benefits of GST 2.0.
Understanding GST 2.0: A Simplified Tax Structure
The current GST framework operates with four primary tax slabs: 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%, alongside special rates for certain items. According to reports, GST 2.0 proposes reducing this to a two-tier structure of 5% and 18%, with a special 40% rate applied to select demerit goods like pan masala, tobacco, and online gaming. Approximately 90% of items currently taxed at 28% may shift to the 18% slab, and many in the 12% bracket could move to 5%. This restructuring aims to categorize goods into "merit" (essential) and "standard" groups, making essentials more affordable while maintaining higher taxes on luxury or sin goods.
The effective weighted average GST rate, which has already declined from 14.4% in 2017 to 11.6% by September 2019, is projected to drop further to 9.5% with these reforms. While this simplification is expected to reduce government revenue by ₹85,000 crore annually, it is also anticipated to drive significant economic benefits.
The Revenue Loss: A ₹85,000 Crore Challenge
The estimated ₹85,000 crore annual revenue loss, as highlighted by SBI Research, stems from the reduction in tax rates on a wide range of goods and services. For instance, household essentials, air conditioners, televisions, small cars, insurance premiums, and telecom services may see tax rates drop from 18% or 28% to 5% or 18%. This reduction directly impacts the combined revenue of the central and state governments, with some independent estimates, like those from HSBC, suggesting losses could be as high as ₹1.43 lakh crore (0.4% of GDP).
For the fiscal year 2025-26, assuming the new rates are implemented from October to March, the revenue shortfall is estimated at ₹45,000 crore. This loss could temporarily increase the fiscal deficit by 0.2% of GDP, posing a challenge to fiscal planning. States, in particular, have expressed concerns about the revenue impact, with potential losses of up to ₹9,000 crore annually for some. Despite these challenges, the government remains optimistic, citing the short-term nature of the revenue dip and the potential for long-term economic gains.
Boosting Consumption: A ₹1.98 Lakh Crore Opportunity
The core argument for GST 2.0’s economic benefits lies in its potential to boost consumption by ₹1.98 lakh crore annually, as projected by SBI Research. Lower tax rates on essentials and household goods reduce the cost of living, leaving consumers with more disposable income. For example, reduced GST rates on daily necessities, packaged foods, and telecom services could make these items more affordable, encouraging higher spending. Similarly, lower taxes on big-ticket items like small cars and electronics could stimulate demand in these sectors.
This consumption boost, equivalent to approximately 1.6% of GDP, is expected to create a ripple effect across the economy. Increased consumer spending drives demand for goods and services, prompting businesses to ramp up production, invest in expansion, and create jobs. The SBI report also suggests that, combined with recent income tax cuts, the total consumption expenditure could rise by ₹5.31 lakh crore, further amplifying economic activity.
Economic Momentum: How GST 2.0 Drives Growth
The projected economic momentum from GST 2.0 stems from several key factors:
Simplified Tax Structure: A two-tier GST system reduces complexity for businesses, lowering compliance costs and improving ease of doing business. This simplification encourages investment and operational efficiency, fostering economic growth.
Increased Consumption: As mentioned, the ₹1.98 lakh crore consumption boost directly stimulates demand. This increased economic activity could lead to a 0.6% rise in GDP, according to SBI Research, offsetting the initial revenue loss over time.
Improved Compliance: A simpler tax regime reduces tax evasion and improves compliance. The government expects that enhanced compliance, coupled with increased economic activity, will mitigate revenue losses within six months, as noted by official sources.
Lower Inflation: Lower tax rates on essentials could reduce consumer prices, easing inflation by 50–60 basis points over the next year, according to Emkay Research. Lower inflation preserves purchasing power, further supporting consumption-driven growth.
Support for Long-Term Growth: By making goods and services more affordable, GST 2.0 aligns with the government’s vision of “one nation, one tax” by 2047. This reform strengthens the foundation for a unified market, promoting economic integration and efficiency.
Challenges and Considerations
While the potential benefits are significant, GST 2.0 faces challenges that must be addressed:
- Fiscal Strain: The immediate revenue loss could strain government finances, particularly if capital expenditure or social sector programs face cuts. Balancing fiscal discipline with economic stimulus will be critical.
- State Consensus: GST reforms require approval from at least 20 states, representing a 75% weighted majority in the GST Council. States’ concerns about revenue losses must be addressed to ensure consensus.
- Input Tax Credit (ITC) Limitations: For 99% of items moving from 12% to 5%, input tax credits may not be available, potentially increasing costs for businesses in certain sectors. This could offset some of the consumption gains if not carefully managed.
The Road Ahead: A “Double Diwali” for Consumers?
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has described GST 2.0 as a “double Diwali” gift, emphasizing its potential to lower costs for consumers while simplifying the tax system. The reforms, set to be discussed by a panel of state finance ministers and the GST Council in September 2025, aim to build on the success of GST 1.0, which unified India’s market and boosted annual revenue growth by over 18% since 2017.
While critics, including the Congress party, argue that GST 2.0 highlights flaws in the original GST framework, the government views it as a step toward long-term economic resilience. By prioritizing consumption, simplifying compliance, and fostering growth, GST 2.0 could unlock significant economic potential, even if it comes at the cost of short-term revenue losses.
Conclusion
GST 2.0 represents a bold move to balance immediate fiscal challenges with long-term economic gains. The projected ₹85,000 crore revenue loss is a significant hurdle, but the anticipated ₹1.98 lakh crore consumption boost, coupled with reduced inflation and improved compliance, could propel India’s economy forward. As the GST Council deliberates on these reforms, the focus will be on ensuring that the benefits of increased consumption and economic momentum outweigh the fiscal costs, paving the way for a stronger, more integrated Indian economy.
Sources:
